Click on a page icon to download the report in PDF format, or use text links to jump to short report descriptions. To view PDF files you will need a copy of Adobe Acrobat Reader version 3.0 or higher. To download a free copy of Reader
click here.

April 2003, Volume 23

EMPLOYMENT LAW

GENERAL TORTS

INSURANCE COVERAGE

INTERNATIONAL LAW

TOXIC TORTS/ENVIRONMENT

PRODUCT LAW

BUSINESS LAW

NURSING HOME LAW


EMPLOYMENT LAW

RACE DISCRIMINATION
Summary Judgment Precluded When Genuineness of Reason For Termination Questionable

ADEA AND RACE DISCRIMINATION
Failure to Promote Did Not Constitute Adverse Employment Action

RACE DISCRIMNATION AND RETALIATION
Employee Not Meeting Employer’s Legitimate Job Expectations Does Not Establish Prima Facie Case of Discrimination

ADA
Home Office Not Reasonable Accommodation

SEXUAL HARASSMENT
Plaintiff Failed to Establish Retaliation Under Either Direct or Indirect Methods

Agency’s Investigation of Sexual Harassment Claim Did Not Constitute Sexual Harassment

ADEA
Status As Shareholder Precluded Suit Pursuant To ADEA

NATIONAL ORIGIN AND GENDER
Ministerial Status Precludes Subject Matter Jurisdiction

BACK TO TOP


GENERAL TORTS

WRONGFUL DEATH
Named Driver Exclusions Do Not Violate Illinois Public Policy

DUTY
Absent Showing Of Failure To Exercise Due Care, Golfer Not Liable For Hitting Other Golfer Within “Zone Of Danger”

Contractor Had Duty To Warn Motorcyclist Of Uneven Surfaces In Recently Paved Roadway

Failure To Prepare For Anticipated Snowfall Provided Basis For Breach Of Duty To Provide Safe Workplace

PREMISES LIABILITY
No Duty To Protect Grocery Store Customers From Unsupervised Child With Shopping Cart

Municipality Immune From Liability Stemming From Allegedly Dangerous Condition On Bicycle Trail

Parking Lot, For Which Employer Reimbursed Expenses, Was Not “Provided By” Employer

FEDERAL PREEMPTION OF STATE TORT CLAIM
Plaintiff’s Action Citing Garbage Truck’s “Flimsy” Door And Exposed Door Handle Preempted By Federal Safety Statute

DAMAGES
Case May Not Continue Against One Defendant After Plaintiff Paid Full Amount Of Damages From Other Defendant

BACK TO TOP


INSURANCE COVERAGE

No Duty To Defend Or Indemnify In Suit Seeking Reimbursement For Environmental Remediation Expenses Under Asset Purchase Agreement

Complaint Need Not Affirmatively Allege Facts In Support Of Imputed Liability

Insured That Waives Kotecki Cap In Construction Contract Has Entered Into “Insured Contract”

Considerations In Determining Whether Policy Is Truly Excess

No Duty To Indemnify Third Party Beneficiary Unless Named As Insured Or Added As An Additional Insured

Court Rejects Arguments That Prior Publication Exclusion Bars Coverage For Ongoing Advertising Campaign

BACK TO TOP


INTERNATIONAL LAW

CONTRACT LAW
Forum Selection Clause Is Merely Permissive Not Mandatory

German Successor Company Entitled To Benefit From Predecessor’s Confidentiality Agreement Between Predecessor And Employee

PERSONAL JURISDICTION
Spanish Company’s Interactive Website With Sporadic Other Contacts Not Enough To Satisfy Requirements For Personal Jurisdiction

FORUM NON CONVENIENS
Austria’s Motion To Dismiss Properly Denied In Action To Recover Famous Paintings Confiscated By The Nazis During World War II

BACK TO TOP


TOXIC TORTS/ENVIRONMENT

CLEAN WATER ACT
Louisiana Environmental Quality Act Found to be Comparable to the CWA

CERCLA
Joint and Several Liability Addressed Under CERCLA

ENDANGERED SPECIES ACT LITIGATION
Former Circus Handler Found to have Standing to Pursue Claim

ESA “Take” Provision Upheld as Constitutional

ILLINOIS SPORTS FACILITIES AUTHORITY ACT
Soldier Field Renovation Receives Supreme Court Approval

POLLUTION COTROL FACILITY EXEMPTION OF THE ILLINOIS USE TAX ACT
Primary Purpose Analysis Denies Tax Exemption

BACK TO TOP


PRODUCT LAW

PUBLIC HEALTH
New York District Court Dismisses “McProducts” Liability Lawsuit

Dangers Of Diet Pills Not As Obvious

LIMITATIONS OF ACTIONS
Mere Suspicion That Chromium Containing Wood Stain Caused Leg Injury Insufficient To Trigger Indiana Product’s Liability Statute Of Limitations

Indiana Supreme Court Upholds Constitutionality Of Statute Of Repose

CHOICE OF PRODUCTS LIABILITY LAW
Site Of Injury Continues Be Benchmark For Products Liability Claims In Washington State

FEDERAL PREEMPTION
State Court Class Action Law Suit To Protect Cell Phone Users From Radio Frequency Radiation Preempted By Federal Law

Federal Consumer Protection Act Expressly Preempts State Law Toy Warning Labeling Case

PROXIMATE CAUSE
“Group Liability” Or “Collective Civil Conspiracy” Theory Not Applicable In Asbestos Case

BACK TO TOP


BUSINESS LAW

BUSINESS ASSOCIATIONS
Joint Venture Does Not Arise By Virtue of Contractual Relationship Between Parties

BUSINESS CORPORATION ACT
Corporate Officer Personally Liable For Debts When Conducting Corporation’s Business Arising After Corporation Is Involuntary Dissolved And Before Reinstatement

MECHANICS LIEN ACT
Recording Of Mechanics Lien Not Sufficient Notice When Owner’s Representative Can Be Found In County Where Improvement Made

Service of Notice of Mechanics Lien By Facsimile Not Sufficient Under Section 24

CONTRACTS
Right Of First Refusal Clause Must Contain Definite and Certain Price Term Or Establish Method For Determining Price

Settlement Offer Must Limit Itself By Its Own Terms And Conditions

BACK TO TOP


NURSING HOME LAW

PRE-SUIT REQUIREMENTS
Affidavit Of Consultation With Medical Professional Not Applicable To All Cases Against Medical Profession

JURISDICTION
Duties Under Doctor-Patient Relationship Independent Of Facility’s State Affiliation

STATUTORY CAUSE OF ACTION
State Statute Designed To Expand Resident’s Right To Sue

Florida Court Holds Damages Under State’s Nursing Home Act Are Separate and Distinct From State’s Wrongful Death Act

Estate of Deceased Nursing Home Resident Can Recover Survivor’s Damages When Cause of Action Solely Based on Florida’s Nursing Home Act

VICARIOUS LIABILITY
Nursing Home Liability For Employees’ Intentional Torts

PRIVILEGED DOCUMENTS
Documents Produced Pursuant To State Or Federal Law Are Not Privileged

BACK TO TOP