Click on a page icon to download the report in PDF format, or use text links to jump to short report descriptions. To view PDF files you will need a copy of Adobe Acrobat Reader version 3.0 or higher. To download a free copy of Reader
click here.

October 2004, Volume 30

EMPLOYMENT LAW

GENERAL TORTS

INSURANCE COVERAGE

INTERNATIONAL LAW

TOXIC TORTS/ENVIRONMENT

PRODUCT LAW

BUSINESS LAW

NURSING HOME LAW


EMPLOYMENT LAW

GENDER DISCRIMINATION
Punitive Damages Award Excessive Considering Employer’s Prompt Action to Remedy

TITLE VII
Arbitration Clause Enforceable In Title VII Dispute

SEXUAL HARASSMENT
Eighth Circuit Finds Defendant Entitled to Modified Faragher/Ellerth Affirmative Defense

ADEA
Plaintiff Fails to Establish a Prima Facie Case of Age Discrimination

AGE/RACE/RETALIATION
Employer’s Proffered Reason for Failing to Select Employee for Position Was Not Pretext

AGE DISCRIMINATION
Termination for Violation of Residency Requirement Not Pretext For Age Discrimination

RETALIATION
Case Remanded to Determine Whether Indefinite Suspension Became Actual Termination

BACK TO TOP


GENERAL TORTS

EXPERT TESTIMONY
Doctors Not Competent To Offer Opinion Testimony Regarding Nurses

DUTY
Clinic Did Not Have Duty Of Care To Report Child Abuse

No Duty Of Care For Landowners To Warn Of Dangers Of Trampoline

No Duty To Equip Facility With Cardiac Defibrillators

PROTECTIVE ORDERS
Protection Of Identities Of Sexual Abuse Victims

BACK TO TOP


INSURANCE COVERAGE

Notice to CGL Carrier Three Years After Suits Filed Not Violation of Notice Condition Where Suits Initially Defended By Liquidated “Wrap-Up” Carrier

Carrier Estopped From Raising Policy Defenses Where Reservation of Rights Letter Inadequately Advised Insured of Conflict of Interest

Carrier Not Entitled to Setoff From UM Limits Pension Payments Made to Insured

Insured Could Not Trigger Indemnity Clause By Violating Voluntary Pollution Cleanup Agreement and Forcing EPA To Order Cleanup

I
nnocent Insured Entitled to Coverage Where Other Insureds Intentionally Caused Loss

Federal District Court Impliedly Endorses Targeted Tender to Excess Carrier

BACK TO TOP


INTERNATIONAL LAW

PERSONAL JURISDICTION
No General Jurisdiction In Illinois Where Defendant Shipped, Within Mexico, Products From Purported Affiliated Company, Later Shipped To Illinois

Canadian Court Had Personal Jurisdiction Over Illinois Defendant Where Defendant Purposefully Directed Activities At Canada

SUBJECT MATTER JURISDICTION
Court Of International Trade Had Jurisdiction Over Action Brought Under False Claims Act Arising Out Of Importer’s Scheme To Avoid Paying Customs Duties

FORUM NON CONVENIENS
Transfer Of Case To Germany Under Forum Non Conveniens Appropriate Where Plaintiff Voluntarily Entered Into Complex Real Estate Investment While Living In Germany

STANDING
No Article III Standing Where Relief Sought Would Not Redress Injury

BACK TO TOP


TOXIC TORTS/ENVIRONMENT

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT
Animal Rights Group Seeks Court Intervention to Stop Black Bear Hunt

GEORGIA HAZARDOUS SITE RESPONSE ACT
State Seeks Additional Damages For Clean Up

CERCLA
Plaintiff Argues the “Deep Deep Plume” Theory

BACK TO TOP


PRODUCT LAW

SIMPLE PRODUCT LIABILITY
Motorboat Could Not Be Classified As “Simple Product” To Preclude Application Of Danger-Utility Test For Product Defect

FORESEEABLE MISUSE
Use Of Light Fixture Within Feet Of Home Insulation Is Foreseeable

DISCOVERY SANCTIONS
No Sanctions For Failure To Produce Defective Product If Plaintiff Does Not Exercise Reasonable Control Over It

APPARENT MANUFACTURER DOCTRINE
Colorado To Recognize Apparent Manufacturer Doctrine

FEDERAL PREEMPTION
FDA’s Position Regarding Preemption Of Heart Valve Design Was Entitled To Deference

SOPHISTICATED INTERMEDIARY
Helicopter Pilots Were Sophisticated Intermediaries, Precluding Finding Of Liability Against Manufacturer For Failure To Warn Of Dangerous Rotor Blades

BACK TO TOP


BUSINESS LAW

CONTRACT LAW
Illinois Courts Weigh Harm When Ordering Disclosure of Confidential Commercial Information

Liquidated Damages Clause for Commission on Unsold Real Estate Allowed

No Money Owed to Retained Consultant Where Contract to Secure Refunds Terminable At Will

CONSUMER FRAUD
Class Action Arbitrations are Allowed Where Arbitration Agreement Silent as to Class-Wide Relief

MECHANIC’S LIENS
Recording and Registering Multiple Liens not Evidence of Fraud Without Finding of Intent

BUSINESS CORPORATION ACT
Post-Judgment Interest Available to Minority Shareholders Seeking Buyout Under BCA at Discretion of Trial Court

BACK TO TOP


NURSING HOME LAW

MEDICAL MALPRACTICE VS. ORDINARY NEGLIGENCE
Supreme Court of Michigan Held Former Nursing Home Resident’s Estate Could Maintain Medical Malpractice Suit Despite Expiration of Statute of Limitations

DOCUMENT PRODUCTION
Appellate Court in Florida Struck Trial Court’s Order Compelling Nursing Home to Produce Grievance Logs of Consumer and Employee Complaints

CLASS ACTION
Illinois Federal Court Grants Class Action Status to Nursing Home Residents Against State

STATUTORY INTERPRETATION
Illinois Circuit Court Held Plaintiffs Cannot State Wrongful Death or Survival Actions Under Nursing Home Care Act in Illinois

STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS
Tennessee Court Holds Statute of Limitations Tolled for Wrongful Death Action Due to Delayed Discovery

EXPERT WITNESSES
Illinois Court Reaffirms Precedent Requiring Expert Witness Offering Opinions as to Standard of Care for Nurses Be Made By Licensed Nurse

BACK TO TOP